[gnugo-devel] special game

[max-d]

Here is a game played between go++(black)  and go++(white)  helped by gnugo
3.4.

1-Gnugo can reject some go++ moves .
2-When it accepts a move , that does not mean at all that it agrees with it
!!

the game was won by black (go++ alone) but that does not mean anything
about the respective strengh of both programs.

Looking at gnugo comments (at the end of the sgf file) allows to look at the
pertinence of rejections/suggestions  .

The program was set not to allow Gnugo to interact too often in strategical
Go++ moves.

Gnugo seems often much pertinent in semeai moves .
(alone ,go++ should have lost the large upper white group)

Go++ =level 5 (top) for both side
Gnugo= lv 10.

Hope this game is interesting for some of you to analyse !
md.


Game 1
Size 19
Helped 33
Black = go++ White = go++gg 10 4
Time black = 908,4 Time white = 1062,1
Score =  B+1.5
(
;B[dc]
;W[qd]
;B[qq]
;W[dp]
;B[nc]
;W[lc]
;B[qc]
;W[pc]
;B[pd]
;W[qb]
;B[rc]
;W[ic]
;B[qe]
;W[fc]
;B[ce]
;W[od]
;B[pe]
;W[qj]
;B[qh]
;W[qm]
;B[oc]
;W[pp]
;B[pq]
;W[jq]
;B[cn]
;W[dn]
;B[cq]
;W[co]
;B[er]
;W[cm]
;B[ll]
;W[gr]
;B[ch]
;W[qp]
;B[op]
;W[oo]
;B[np]
;W[cj]
;B[rp]
;W[ro]
;B[rq]
;W[dq]
;B[dr]
;W[bq]
;B[br]
;W[bp]
;B[lq]
;W[jo]
;B[di]
;W[pi]
;B[dj]
;W[dk]
;B[ek]
;W[dl]
;B[gf]
;W[om]
;B[im]
;W[hn]
;B[gl]
;W[ie]
;B[ig]
;W[bi]
;B[bh]
;W[fm]
;B[gd]
;W[gc]
;B[hd]
;W[id]
;B[fd]
;W[ec]
;B[db]
;W[lf]
;B[nf]
;W[ed]
;B[ga]
;W[gb]
;B[fa]
;W[ee]
;B[jb]
;W[eg]
;B[fh]
;W[ib]
;B[ia]
;W[ni]
;B[mg]
;W[li]
;B[kh]
;W[lh]
;B[lg]
;W[ki]
;B[ij]
;W[jh]
;B[jg]
;W[ih]
;B[hh]
;W[kf]
;B[kg]
;W[hb]
;B[ha]
;W[ah]
;B[bf]
;W[mb]
;B[so]
;W[nb]
;B[ob]
;W[rn]
;B[jf]
;W[ld]
;B[mf]
;W[me]
;B[ke]
;W[kd]
;B[qi]
;W[nd]
;B[oa]
;W[na]
;B[pb]
;W[jc]
;B[kb]
;W[je]
;B[le]
;W[mc]
;B[rj]
;W[la]
;B[ol]
;W[pl]
;B[pn]
;W[on]
;B[rl]
;W[ok]
;B[qk]
;W[pj]
;B[lo]
;W[pk]
;B[oh]
;W[nl]
;B[mk]
;W[ph]
;B[qg]
;W[kf]
;B[lf]
;W[jj]
;B[gm]
;W[gn]
;B[jk]
;W[kr]
;B[lr]
;W[kk]
;B[jl]
;W[ls]
;B[ms]
;W[ks]
;B[nr]
;W[ql]
;B[rk]
;W[el]
;B[fk]
;W[af]
;B[ae]
;W[ag]
;B[bg]
;W[ai]
;B[bd]
;W[kl]
;B[km]
;W[nh]
;B[ci]
;W[bj]
;B[og]
;W[lk]
;B[ml]
;W[mm]
;B[lm]
;W[mn]
;B[ii]
;W[ji]
;B[rm]
;W[qn]
;B[sn]
;W[kp]
;B[in]
;W[io]
;B[lp]
;W[mj]
;B[mh]
;W[mi]
;B[nk]
;W[nj]
;B[oi]
;W[oj]
;B[pg]
;W[ge]
;B[he]
;W[fe]
;B[hf]
;W[mo]
;B[mp]
;W[hm]
;B[hl]
;W[no]
;B[kq]
;W[jr]
;B[ko]
;W[jp]
;B[jn]
;W[lb]
;B[ja]
;W[kc]
;B[fg]
;W[df]
;B[ne]
;W[md]
;B[ff]
;W[ef]
;B[eb]
;W[dd]
;B[cd]
;W[eh]
;B[ei]
;W[oe]
;B[of]
;W[ln]
;B[kn]
;W[fb]
;B[ea]
;W[ar]
;B[cf]
;W[dg]
;B[if]
;W[fl]
;B[hr]
;W[hq]
;B[gq]
;W[ir]
;B[hp]
;W[hs]
;B[bk]
;W[ck]
;B[fn]
;W[ho]
;B[cg]
;W[en]
;B[fo]
;W[fq]
;B[po]
;W[qo]
;B[hc]
;W[ka]
;B[rd]
;W[cc]
;B[cb]
;W[de]
;B[ng]
;W[dh]
)

move 6 rejected : R13 >> 6 M17
top moves= M17 35.01 P16 35.00 Q17 35.00 R13 25.61 C15 25.12 D15 25.12 O4
24.41 Q4 24.41 Q6 24.40 O15 22.17
move 10 rejected : R15 >> 10 R18
top moves= R18 37.87 Q18 33.87 R15 32.15 P17 26.71 C15 25.12 D15 25.12 O4
24.41 Q4 24.41 Q6 24.40 J17 24.11
move 16 rejected : R9 >> 16 P16
top moves= P16 31.74 P17 29.73 O4 24.41 Q4 24.41 Q6 24.40 C10 16.58 K4 16.27
D10 16.26 N15 16.17 C8 16.13
move 22 rejected : K3 >> 22 Q4
top moves= Q4 24.41 C10 16.58 K4 16.27 D10 16.26 C8 15.97 C6 15.77 F3 15.76
P10 14.47 E8 13.99 Q5 11.46
move 26 rejected : F4 >> 26 D6
top moves= D6 24.16 F4 24.13 F3 24.13 C8 24.12 R4 19.10 C5 18.07 E5 17.82 F5
17.53 B5 17.43 E6 17.07
move 28 rejected : D3 >> 28 C5
top moves= C5 35.00 D3 35.00 C7 32.13 E3 27.27 F3 20.63 R4 19.11 Q5 16.53 D8
16.15 N3 16.07 G3 16.07
move 36 rejected : C10 >> 36 P5
top moves= P5 35.00 N3 24.11 C10 16.26 O15 11.84 B6 10.47 M15 10.40 M2 9.60
B4 9.52 M14 9.29 P10 9.20
move 52 rejected : P7 >> 52 D9
top moves= D9 18.75 B10 12.18 C8 10.24 E8 10.19 R5 10.17 F15 9.77 C9 9.75 F7
9.73 F8 9.70 Q5 9.68
move 76 rejected : H18 >> 76 G18
top moves= G18 23.71 H17 20.40 J18 14.07 K18 13.06 M10 11.55 N11 9.46 M12
9.33 N10 9.14 O10 8.43 O11 8.42
move 78 rejected : H18 >> 78 E15
top moves= E15 19.56 M12 13.61 M10 11.23 M11 9.37 N11 9.23 N10 8.91 O10 8.23
O11 8.19 L2 7.70 O12 7.65
move 80 rejected : O11 >> 80 E13
top moves= E13 28.36 J18 21.06 K17 13.91 N13 13.52 M10 11.25 N11 9.33 M12
9.17 N10 9.01 O11 8.35 O10 8.35
move 82 rejected : O11 >> 82 J18
top moves= J18 21.40 K17 14.24 N13 12.76 M10 10.88 N11 9.16 M12 9.00 N10
8.87 O10 8.28 O11 8.27 L2 7.70
move 88 rejected : H18 >> 88 M12
top moves= M12 20.22 M13 18.67 L11 10.94 L2 7.70 S11 6.91 N9 6.45 A12 5.50
T5 5.47 O9 5.09 N18 4.41
move 96 rejected : A12 >> 96 L14
top moves= L14 17.36 K14 16.84 M15 14.81 L15 14.01 L13 9.31 N15 7.98 L2 7.70
S11 6.90 K10 6.19 N9 5.79
move 102 rejected : K11 >> 102 N18
top moves= N18 78.60 L2 7.70 S11 6.90 A13 5.97 N9 5.82 J11 5.48 T5 5.47 O9
4.87 K11 4.30 K10 4.12
move 104 rejected : P19 >> 104 O18
top moves= O18 77.40 M19 74.62 P18 21.05 S6 15.94 R5 11.28 Q5 9.59 R6 9.13
L2 7.70 S11 6.27 M6 6.03
move 106 rejected : Q18 >> 106 S6
top moves= S6 15.94 R5 11.28 Q5 9.59 R6 9.13 L2 7.70 S11 6.27 M6 6.03 N9
5.90 A13 5.72 J11 5.50
move 108 rejected : K11 >> 108 M16
top moves= M16 61.37 M15 57.34 L17 56.42 K17 56.27 N15 55.16 K16 52.55 N16
24.95 L16 23.61 L15 19.64 L18 19.38
move 110 rejected : K11 >> 110 N15
top moves= N15 23.29 K15 22.00 L2 7.70 O16 6.95 S11 6.86 N9 5.79 A13 5.72
J11 5.47 O9 4.84 K11 4.29
move 112 rejected : K11 >> 112 L16
top moves= L16 72.74 K17 29.27 O15 29.15 P15 28.77 M19 25.95 L2 7.70 S11
6.86 A13 5.97 N9 5.79 J11 5.47
move 114 rejected : Q9 >> 114 O16
top moves= O16 85.73 P15 79.53 M19 75.27 S10 11.83 L2 7.70 O15 6.68 A13 5.97
N9 5.86 J11 5.47 O9 4.91
move 116 rejected : Q9 >> 116 O19
top moves= O19 82.93 S10 11.83 L2 7.70 A13 5.97 N9 5.86 J11 5.47 O9 4.92 K11
4.29 K10 4.11 Q10 3.78
move 118 rejected : Q9 >> 118 K17
top moves= K17 73.94 S10 11.83 L2 7.70 A13 5.97 N9 5.86 J11 5.47 O9 4.92 K11
4.29 K10 4.11 P13 3.78
move 120 rejected : Q9 >> 120 K15
top moves= K15 78.87 S10 11.83 L2 7.70 A13 5.97 N9 5.86 J11 5.47 O9 4.92 K11
4.29 K10 4.11 P13 3.78
move 122 rejected : Q9 >> 122 N17
top moves= N17 19.85 S10 11.83 L2 7.70 N9 5.86 A13 5.72 M18 5.53 J11 5.47
N16 5.22 O9 4.92 K11 4.29
move 124 rejected : O9 >> 124 M19
top moves= M19 81.58 L17 80.86 R9 16.43 Q10 8.52 L2 7.70 K10 6.42 A13 5.97
P10 5.77 J11 5.50 Q9 5.40
move 126 rejected : L6 >> 126 Q8
top moves= Q8 15.08 M6 11.03 K10 7.89 L2 7.71 J11 6.67 T6 5.66 A13 5.66 K11
5.64 Q10 4.70 R9 4.39
move 128 rejected : P9 >> 128 P6
top moves= P6 37.57 O5 30.82 O6 25.90 O8 21.71 R9 21.24 Q5 8.65 L2 7.72 R5
7.33 K10 7.17 J11 6.01
move 132 rejected : O8 >> 132 Q10
top moves= Q10 19.02 O8 13.74 M6 8.19 L2 7.70 K10 6.47 A13 5.66 J11 5.53 K11
4.35 Q12 3.56 P13 3.48
move 136 rejected : N9 >> 136 O8
top moves= O8 12.57 L2 7.72 K10 6.29 A13 5.66 J11 5.52 K11 4.35 M2 3.49 L9
3.04 J6 2.98 Q12 2.65
move 160 rejected : L8 >> 160 A13
top moves= A13 9.01 O12 5.81 P13 5.21 Q13 3.51 E12 2.45 N6 2.38 F13 2.32 P11
2.07 J11 2.05 N7 1.83
move 172 rejected : N10 >> 172 N7
top moves= N7 7.02 N10 6.52 N6 3.16 E12 2.48 F13 2.33 O7 2.08 J11 2.05 P11
1.08 J6 1.03 F15 0.08
move 188 rejected : P11 >> 188 O10
top moves= O10 37.98 P11 37.28 P10 34.41 E12 2.48 F13 2.33 N5 1.54 K6 1.04
F15 0.08 L6 0.01