Re: worse slur positioning

[Erik Sandberg]

Thanks, added as slur-broken2.

On Sunday 10 October 2004 14.30, Werner LEMBERG wrote:
> [The linewidth parameter still doesn't produce a staff with a length
>  of 70mm!]
>
> %
> % address@hidden
>
> \version "2.3.21"
>
> \header { texidoc = "
> Compared to 2.3.20, the vertical start position of the slur after
> the break is worse in the example below: It was about one staff line
> higher.  The current behaviour is not aesthetically pleasing since the
> slur starts in a vertical range which is rather reserved for ties.
> " }
>
>
> \score {
>   \relative c'' {
>     a2( c | g2 d | b'2 e, ~ | \break
>     e1 ~ | e1 | e1) |
>   }
>
>   \paper {
>     indent = 0.0\mm
>     linewidth = 70.0\mm
>   }
> }
>
> % EOF
>
>
> ======================================================================
>
>
> begin 644 slur.png
> MB5!.1PT*&@address@hidden"`(```!9N5FH````!&=!34$``+&/
> M"_QA!0```#AT15AT4V]F='=A<address@hidden<VEO;address@hidden
> M,B\R.2\Y-"`H4$Y'('!A=&-H(#$N,BG=%2Y)```,B4E$051XVNW=W9:C*!0&
> MT)CE^[^R<U$SF2RCB`K(S]Y7W=75E90>X0LB3,NRO```"'H[!```,A,`@,P$
> M`"`S`0#(3```,A,`@,P$`"`S`0`@,P$`R$P``#(3`(#,!``@,P$`R$P``#(3
> M`(#,!`"`S`0`(#,!`,A,```R$P"`S/2?:9JF:7*X`0"9*1285G\``)"address@hidden
> MV`0`M&MV"*!F37S,6);%F0+Z;Y"S-G9[S;T6%M&$;FC08!#&F9!7H-L"EN<@
> MY<6>[XK:;$>69?G[NBM9MP%T0&/..&:7%AVD'Z6%ZZ6;(^!RIMYJSU2=OU?1
> M]PL9:NJR37="05/@,Q4=FY6L1M#Y`M&AXQR6\$UJ&address@hidden(>.0L`/4W[Y6'
> ML#MO3R,L,]TMOG%JZ,+M2!<G((1U$\*NO1.-^5B9R?G.=#DYL`"%F\KR"2S\
> MBCJ"WC(3-R\_EP1`9PDL5?8R9T-F&CTM*6(`V:O`F%;D2^B5"F4F!SJR3!TH
> M`&[V"YEBUMX*U3(3E5X)4#[6*U3HNW.YD['&G(/[0&:R;"X`M/L!_D(_WL=D
> M=N-,`,#=L)5CU*JV+"address@hidden;EIHJF;T/`%!GX/OS=J0```YEW+WD
> M=VN4U7C54$_E>!")address@hidden&N7*V6A0,address@hidden@XXUN\.?=OXBH"`#+YCAE[^2G5
> MLHCEYH"//,@$`)3,3Y$IZE0:F;.^]<][,HL<`'@V1?VFD5/Y9*[A=P``*!D_
> M5FDI9C91]LQD;S4`>)8'._;RTZEQ)FL-``!#)Z?(0/E^ZLT!`#2D:&82F`"`
> address@hidden>VJ;XU(E;\Q]OX&]%:X*WRCTS,+EFAGST-D[
> MQ4EI[N)U9%1O3QW0IO>#K_U(8'I=>KR0PO6Z+,NI9QD`(+>YL]_G,#!]?X/M
> M\"H,3,X(`'5*/,X4'C`HW/M>^`8J#$S.&@`U2#G.%%[RVZ`.`7NU(3`!%SX,
> MZVZH/3-57K)ZWVI;NL/`I/D#XJ/2-$T^I9/#.VOYELQ/(E&C]N['.:%`?(/O
> MP1%:RDR1'6%M?3-U!B8G#H@,3"5GS2(S9:G@)GIHEUEM;=_O\))S!)SM;HQ2
> MDZO\[)T"``S.WBD``&DDV#LEL(QDY`!5DOLOX94.RK`!R-G#Y8"$:\G>*4Y*
> M*X?E5?!9'_,@56^!OGO3NX8WT<>]OV?7\P08@<address@hidden
> MUS#`_6;address@hidden,TG)GV*O7"H,O-^/address@hidden>(Y#H#RX:F&*1D,I<0>O;]%_/G*LTDB
> M^7P:&X#0:/<#3=>MJ$3#F2DP*WQ9EM6_?O^UQ4G!-@"AFZCT_;P"U$E#RH/>
> M6>address@hidden@"G?E3:?&8#$)H.3/:=`"B7F>XTV>&)4)>S2^!'address@hidden<#D
> MZ4Z`JC-35H>Q*?DR%9[CH-W`5.`"`>BD";5W"@`P.'NG``"DD6SOE+U=4^('
> M_SU?-AI[IYR]K/+]3'>3GSHIW1R6`D?&\7?T<M?PH7>FEW1BH$("$\!E"3+3
> address@hidden>OEU'0H[344^SCE>06`HIGIM;\47B7K?0.KV&3?"8"SLN^=LAFG5LM_
> M"U50P.>Z,[8$(WPTHM[,]-<<[\WJC6R4M=U0X#,,,$Y4LB=20BG7&address@hidden@>EE
> M/C\`I`Y,address@hidden@address@hidden&FO5-E028`2!Z8
> M#K^'BX?:WBD`P.#LG0(`D"`PO2+'F7(PC0E[IU!G6>ZUIUJM&DZ-XQ]_6*PJ
> MDMSL$`#L!2;=#/43F(IQ;address@hidden@]45<"_
> M&VSHB*O.3+]GRX05H"V':Z-`;15K3Z3V,I,&!6CW,WID8-(/T5#0W^NCE?'E
> address@hidden,7>"M.#]!HQ^/3(+U&!%WSA:O[R>?FG#"@H<"DR:+U"O\NZ9%'3R]/_)K+
> MG"<?W8#*V]#OQLJB`PR2G$:H]L/($?_[6I\)X/_8Y,address@hidden&I0Y
> M^ZLEFVQTJJ$QR0FHOYW53#%L\5_+84V\VSMO-4MF"O],L\\`H.,(59MD42=A
> M=HF94"8P`8`(U41(RIB9#F.3-4X`0+JJ)P8]F9E>.S?IK*8%`+2="W.-7YE0
> M"0#(3```0WD[!```,A,`@,P$`"`S`0#(3```,A,`@,P$`"`S`0`@,P$`R$P`
> M`#(3`(#,!``@,P$`R$P``#(3`(#,!`"`S`0`(#,!`,A,```R$P"`S`0`(#,!
> M`,A,``#(3```,A,`@,P$`"`S`0#(3```,A,`@,P$`"`S`0`@,P$`R$P``#(3
> M`(#,!``@,P$`R$P``#(3```R$P"`S`0`(#,!`,A,```R$P"`S`0`(#,!`,A,
> M``#(3```,A,`@,P$`"`S`0#(3```,A,`@,P$`"`S`0`@,P$`R$P``#(3`(#,
> M!``@,P$`R$P``#(3```R$P"`S`0`(#,!`#29F:9I<address@hidden)E)8`(`9*;\IFD2
> MK0"`<3/3-$W+LAQ^S^H/```#9:address@hidden@!&address@hidden/3,%)FK(K\(`-!A
> M9C+(!``,Y4KT"0P4??^TS6];EN7OZR(7`-"0^<+_6<6=^`PD)P$`C<HUG^EW
> MD.D3F/[^8%83`#!09OI>>RGRGAT`0'/FF__?+3D`8`3O!U_;[3D`0&;ZET$F
> M`$!F`@"0F0``*)"9W)@#`&0F``"9*1N/RP$`,A,`@,P$`#"D*6::MKMI`$"O
> M(A]9,\X$``PM<FPH:K^Y:TL&3--Z$&OUGJQ$0)>7G,*FU_)6VXP<F%ZYQYG<
> MU`,`^E#NWIQ!)@!`9MKPG8H,.`$`,M.M.`4`4+\Y]PO\CC`)3`!`<ZPU``!0
> M7V8RR`0`R$P"$P#0)WNG``"CBXE#YC,!`!S+LG?*YKB4&W/TS=XI=%_>:IN^
> M6^]#[P=?&P"@%>[-`0`4STR;*U@:address@hidden:#P!3X5P"`5F3<.\7P$F3Z-(+6
> M"address@hidden,X6;]659M/L,address@hidden',=+==F*9)>X'address@hidden)Z]<ZX`#`X*P#
> M#@"01H)UP%>C4+_?'!BF,I*<5=,#A,W5AG7`<?DK?OJ^6.:L%\SA^[`>?Z_I
> MQSF%MJ[!)(U,>,49:%W&M0;BK\!AYX97FX0T<R!C!3[?GFK>M3;(3(E[_?YB
> M4PUY2&,$/-6V1+:!AJ88*#/M%?K>91"XBAJ-366RD48$Z"!7Q328AW-DH8?,
> M%'address@hidden,:0(`02JRL?W^5XTG'6:F0(address@hidden;7\4)address@hidden;D-IKF3TV
> M1">9:;.(8RJ[Y+8JJ5[(%0M0+$6MFF[K>M!\9CJ;7;YK_3LV)1EJNI^-7(H`
> MM44HFU+P+'NG``"BN;U3``!22+9WRN;MY[W_N'D#[O`6=>1PE]MJ/,(<"[HO
> M;[5-WZUWFLQTYWV<BDW7?A.7,0"06[+,%)C6G3SW"4D`0'N9:2\>_7W]PHBN
> address@hidden;9UV?:address@hidden;Y0W5)V9
> M/G?B+B\(7J#H-S=U66W>address@hidden>:.\H=[,address@hidden&V.A'FPEG8_
> M>2MOE+?R)H?$:UJ>G<!T+6/=O.3"[_SL?X2J>A3EC?)6WN0J2'NG``"#LW<*
> M`$`:TU,W?8O=<MY;.RKRF]T4I^H+6'FCO)4WI1AG`@"0F7S40'F#\@:9Z?*%
> M%_DLABL6Y0W*&_XMO[2%%;]5W"-+:(1O>&^NF0;-7,S*&^6MO&DE,UV8K_=;
> M]#G*?;4^;.!CRNK5+2Q+$[W(7N<1>3%"N\E)>5/27*"4+_R<5-5_*L:=[9R@
> MMFY#B=(WY<W#S6_6=!*H\LUL%']K[\+[N?;3]$\(20`\G)DB%[P_^PYSK-)Q
> M>?U^4'(`,E-4$Q\_R'2APWBD7[ES%U(GAQ(":-1<Y]N*R4.'WY"I=[FS'V1\
> M9ZEK'"H)J0&`!MKY1V9;[]V82]4//=[9/+*KL2[6&address@hidden<P4_IFIGHQK]%FV
> M1SICZB$8`8R>F2)#S"-+639Y8D0K80B`7C/386RRRI%8)LT`(#-M],2?'VYA
> M>^1F`&address@hidden,A,`0/_>address@hidden@,P$`"`S`0#(3```,A,`@,P$`"`S`0#(
> M3```R$P``#(3`(#,!``@,P$`R$P``#(3`(#,!``@,P$`(#,!`,A,```R$P"`
> MS`0`(#,!`,A,```R$P``,A,`@,P$`"`S`0#(3```,A,`@,P$`"`S`0#(3```
> MR$P``#(3`(#,!``@,P$`R$P``#(3`(#,!`"`S`0`(#,!`,A,```R$P!`-?X!
> G%X"VK:VZN8T````'=$E-10?4"@H,'!B<=S`S`````$E%3D2N0F""
> `
> end
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> bug-lilypond mailing list
> address@hidden
> http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/bug-lilypond