[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Chord changes over repeat alternatives
From: |
Yitz Gale |
Subject: |
Chord changes over repeat alternatives |
Date: |
Tue, 8 Aug 2006 11:55:28 +0000 (UTC) |
User-agent: |
Loom/3.14 (http://gmane.org/) |
Using 2.6.3 on Debian testing, a problem
that was reported here over two years ago
(July 2004) as fixed is still occurring.
The Chord Name engraver with chordChanges = #t
does not print the chord at the beginning
of a repeat alternative if the chord at the
end of the previous repeat alternative was
the same. For example:
\chordmode {
\repeat volta 2 {
c2 c
} \alternative { {
f f
} {
f g
} }
c1
}
The F chord at the beginning of the second
repeat alternative is not printed, even though
it is a chord change.
As discussed in the July 2004 thread, the correct
behavior is probably to always print the chord at
the beginning of every alternative except the first
in a volta repeat, even when it is not a chord
change, just like at the beginning of a line.
But the chord should certainly be printed when
it is a change.
A quick glance at the process_music() method of
the Chord_name_engraver in CVS does not reveal
any mention of repeats. So it appears that either
this is a regression, or the fix was never committed.
Thanks,
Yitz
- Chord changes over repeat alternatives,
Yitz Gale <=
- Re: Chord changes over repeat alternatives, Yitz Gale, 2006/08/11
- Re: Chord changes over repeat alternatives, Paul Scott, 2006/08/11
- Re: Chord changes over repeat alternatives, Yitz Gale, 2006/08/12
- Re: Chord changes over repeat alternatives, Paul Scott, 2006/08/12
- Re: Chord changes over repeat alternatives, Yitz Gale, 2006/08/12
- Re: Chord changes over repeat alternatives, Paul Scott, 2006/08/12
- Re: Chord changes over repeat alternatives, Yitz Gale, 2006/08/13
- Re: Chord changes over repeat alternatives, Paul Scott, 2006/08/13
- Re: Chord changes over repeat alternatives, Yitz Gale, 2006/08/14
- Re: Chord changes over repeat alternatives, Graham Percival, 2006/08/20