[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Issue 726 in lilypond: Wrong accidentals alignment when a second occ
Re: Issue 726 in lilypond: Wrong accidentals alignment when a second occurs simultaneously
Mon, 12 Jan 2009 01:36:12 +0100
2009/1/12 Mark Polesky <address@hidden>:
> I don't consider this issue "fixed".
Mark, I've added your comment and your example. However, do keep in
mind that the status for closed issues is "verified", not "fixed", and
this is not "verified" yet.
Another comment: please use extra diplomacy (and patience) whenever
you're trying to help improving LilyPond. While it is fine to say that
"we" should consider taking Ross' examples into account, it might
easily sound rude to say "*i* don't consider this as fixed".
If your opinion is sensible enough (which I believe it is), it will
prevail in the end, but you also have to keep an open mind. Joe has
already (very quickly) addressed one of the problems; moreover, he has
explained us (which I didn't know) that the octave alignment thing was
actually a deliberate rule; so this is strictly speaking not a bug,
since LilyPond does what it's told to. Determining whether this rule
is good or not is a different debate, that will take more time to