Re: Issue 881 in lilypond: Arpeggios may collide with laissezVibrer ties

[lilypond]

Comment #7 on issue 881 by Carl.D.Sorensen: Arpeggios may collide with  
laissezVibrer ties
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=881

I don't think it's really skylining code.  If I set the Ties Up and then  
shift the leading notes down, the ties aren't
part of the skyline, but they still overlap the arpeggios.

#(ly:set-option 'debug-skylines)
on "2.12.1" % regression: 2.10.33 and 2.8.8 are ok

{
\override LaissezVibrerTie #'direction = #UP
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <f  a'> \arpeggio
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <g  a'> \arpeggio \mark "never"
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <a  a'> \arpeggio
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <b  a'> \arpeggio
 \bar "||"
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <f  g'> \arpeggio
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <g  g'> \arpeggio \mark "sometimes"
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <a  g'> \arpeggio
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <b  g'> \arpeggio
 \bar "||"
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <f  e'> \arpeggio
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <g  e'> \arpeggio \mark "always"
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <a  e'> \arpeggio
 <e'>\laissezVibrer <b  e'> \arpeggio
 }


I'm starting to suspect that it may be a bad bounding box on the arpeggio.   
Notice that the skyline (like the
laissezVibrer) cuts through the end of the arpeggio.


--
You received this message because you are listed in the owner
or CC fields of this issue, or because you starred this issue.
You may adjust your issue notification preferences at:
http://code.google.com/hosting/settings