Issue 1399 in lilypond: extraNatural is quietly set to #f as part of setting the modern-* or piano-* styles

[lilypond]

Status: Accepted
Owner: ----
Labels: Type-Other Priority-Medium

New issue 1399 by brownian.box: extraNatural is quietly set to #f as part  
of setting the modern-* or piano-* styles
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=1399

Reported by Keith E OHara,
http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/bug-lilypond/2010-11/msg00057.html

%----------------------------------------------

% Low priority, but easy, Enhancement, or possibly Documentation
%
% extraNatural is quietly set to #f as part of setting the
% modern-* or piano-* styles for automatic accidentals
%  (music-functions.scm)
% This can be a confusing surprise to users not yet
%  familiar with what extraNatural does :
{
    #(set-accidental-style 'piano 'Score)
    \key des \major  <des' f' aes'>1 \bar "||"
    \key cis \minor  <cis' e' gis'>1
}
% Suggest instead that choosing these styles for automatic
%  accidentals should set extraNatural
%  to the documented default of #t

%----------------------------------------------

I've set its type to "Other" -- please decide whether it should be Doc or  
Enhancement. Thanks.

Attachments:
        nontraditional.png  6.4 KB