Re: woodwind-diagram clarinet

[Markus Schnider]

Hallo

It was always a bad result because a beginner could be irritated by the wrong 
key names. For each other instrument it could be correct, but for clarinets 
the key names are wrong (I could only evaluate the names for saxophone).

The names were inherited from the oboe. (ees is wrong!)

I have also structured the names of the keys:
'low-': only for the lowest notes (not available a duodecim higher)

example:

wrong:
e,4^\markup {
  \woodwind-diagram
    #'clarinet
    #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
       (lh . (thumb ))
       (rh . (ees)))
}_\markup e

correct
e,4^\markup {
  \woodwind-diagram
    #'clarinet
    #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
       (lh . (thumb ))
       (rh . (e)))
}_\markup e

Kind regards

Markus Schnider

On Monday 14 February 2011 12:24:12 Dmytro O. Redchuk wrote:
> On Thu 30 Dec 2010, 22:37 Markus Schnider wrote:
> > Hallo
> 
> Hi!
> 
> Please (if this is actual so far), would you provide a minimal example
> which shows *bad* result and explain why it's bad?
> 
> > version 2.13.44 (2.13.45?)
> > file: define-woodwind-diagrams.scm
> > 
> > 
> > The definitions of the keys for clarinet are for the right hand wrong:
> > (rh . (ees)) should be (rh . (e))
> > (rh . (gis)) should be (rh . (f))
> > (rh . (e)) should be (rh . (gis))
> > 
> > 
> > bass-clarinet
> > (rh . (f)) should be (rh . (ees)) or (rh . (dis))
> > 
> > 
> > For both types (normal and bass clarinet) there exists also an additional
> > key for the left hand -> low-gis.
> > For the bass-clarinet there exists also 5 other keys:
> > low-d for the little finger of the left hand
> > low-d for the little finger of the right hand
> > low-d for the thumb of the right hand
> > low-cis for the thumb of the right hand
> > low-c for the thumb of the right hand
> > 
> > 
> > for more informations (images) there exisits a excellent site:
> > http://www.wfg.woodwind.org/clarinet/basscl_alt_1.html
> > 
> > 
> > thanks
> > 
> > 
> > 
> > 
> > I had to type followings to receive a correct image
> > clarinet = \relative c' {
> > 
> >   s2
> >   e,4^\markup {
> >   
> >     \woodwind-diagram
> >     
> >       #'clarinet
> >       #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
> >       
> >          (lh . (thumb ))
> >          (rh . (ees)))
> >   
> >   }_\markup e
> >   s2.
> >   e4^\markup {
> >   
> >     \woodwind-diagram
> >     
> >       #'clarinet
> >       #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
> >       
> >          (lh . (thumb f))
> >          (rh . (ees)))
> >   
> >   }_\markup e
> >   s2.
> >   e4^\markup {
> >   
> >     \woodwind-diagram
> >     
> >       #'clarinet
> >       #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
> >       
> >          (lh . (thumb e))
> >          (rh . ()))
> >   
> >   }_\markup e
> >   s2.
> >   e4^\markup {
> >   
> >     \woodwind-diagram
> >     
> >       #'clarinet
> >       #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
> >       
> >          (lh . (thumb e))
> >          (rh . (gis)))
> >   
> >   }_\markup e
> >   s2.
> >   f4^\markup {
> >   
> >     \woodwind-diagram
> >     
> >       #'clarinet
> >       #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
> >       
> >          (lh . (thumb ))
> >          (rh . (gis)))
> >   
> >   }_\markup f
> >   s2.
> >   f4^\markup {
> >   
> >     \woodwind-diagram
> >     
> >       #'clarinet
> >       #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
> >       
> >          (lh . (thumb f))
> >          (rh . ()))
> >   
> >   }_\markup f
> >   s2.
> >   fis4^\markup {
> >   
> >     \woodwind-diagram
> >     
> >       #'clarinet
> >       #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
> >       
> >          (lh . (thumb fis))
> >          (rh . ()))
> >     
> >     }_\markup fis ges_\markup ges
> >   
> >   s2
> >   fis4^\markup {
> >   
> >     \woodwind-diagram
> >     
> >       #'clarinet
> >       #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
> >       
> >          (lh . (thumb ))
> >          (rh . (fis)))
> >   
> >   }_\markup fis ges_\markup ges
> >   s2
> >   g4^\markup {
> >   
> >     \woodwind-diagram
> >     
> >       #'clarinet
> >       #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
> >       
> >          (lh . (thumb ))
> >          (rh . ()))
> >   
> >   }_\markup g
> >   s2.
> >   gis4^\markup {
> >   
> >     \woodwind-diagram
> >     
> >       #'clarinet
> >       #'((cc . (one two three four five six))
> >       
> >          (lh . (thumb ))
> >          (rh . (e)))
> >   
> >   }_\markup gis as_\markup as
> > 
> > }
> > 
> > _______________________________________________
> > bug-lilypond mailing list
> > address@hidden
> > http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/bug-lilypond