Re: \pitchedTrill causes warning when used with tie

[Jeremy Crabtree]

On Mar 14, 2011, at 6:23 AM, James Lowe wrote:

> Phil
> 
> )-----Original Message-----
> )From: address@hidden
> )[mailto:address@hidden On
> )Behalf Of Dmytro O. Redchuk
> )Sent: 14 March 2011 09:01
> )To: Jeremy Crabtree
> )Cc: address@hidden
> )Subject: Re: \pitchedTrill causes warning when used with tie
> )
> )On Wed 09 Mar 2011, 17:36 Jeremy Crabtree wrote:
> )> This code
> )>
> )> \relative c''
> )> {
> )> \pitchedTrill b1~\startTrillSpan c | b2.~ b8\stopTrillSpan r8 }
> )>
> )> \version "2.13.51"
> )>
> )>
> )> Will result in:
> )>
> )> pitchedtrillbug.ly:3:17: warning: unterminated tie \pitchedTrill b1~
> )>                  \startTrillSpan c | b2.~ b8\stopTrillSpan r8
> )I believe, Phil's suggestion (\set tieWaitForNote = ##t) did the trick?
> )
> )--
> 
> if you can suggest something for the documentation - I don't think this is a 
> bug but may catch some users out - so it could be an @knownissue 
> candidate/snippet etc.?
> 
> or perhaps we can add this as an enhancement to try to catch pitched trills 
> and ignore them in the case of ties?
> 

It would have been even more frustrating to have lilypond ignore the pitched 
trill.  This is a legitimate notation for wind instruments. (I was separating a 
part from an existing score).  To my mind it would be more logical to be able 
to attach to the trill pitch to the not being trilled, i.e.

b4~\startTrillSpan\trillPitch c

rather than having the note as an argument to \pitchedTrill 

> James
> 
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> bug-lilypond mailing list
> address@hidden
> http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/bug-lilypond