Re: Issue 1643 in lilypond: Part Combine problems

[David Kastrup]

address@hidden writes:

> Updates:
>       Status: Invalid
>
> Comment #1 on issue 1643 by address@hidden: Part Combine problems
> http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=1643
>
> The NR at 1.3.2 says, wrt slurs but I think it would apply to all such
> objects: In polyphonic music, a slur must be terminated in the same
> voice it began.  I think the issue is invalid, as movong from one mode
> to another of partCombine is sure to involve changing voices.

I can't see that it invalid since the distribution into separate voices
is not specified by the user, but happens unter control of the part
combiner.  So it would be the task of the part combiner to apply the
sort of trickery demanded from users when they have to slur across
voices.

The issue might be postponed, or even wontfix, but the status "Invalid"
does not seem appropriate to me.

-- 
David Kastrup