Re: Issue 298 in lilypond: Ties do not appear when shortened because of an accidental

[lilypond]

Updates:
	Labels: -Type-Enhancement -Priority-Medium -Engraving-nitpick Type-Defect  
Needs-design

Comment #7 on issue 298 by address@hidden: Ties do not appear  
when shortened because of an accidental
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=298

I don't regard this as an enhancement.  Incorrect output is produced (the  
tie is effectively missing), so this is a defect.  A view on the correct  
design is needed before work can begin: should the tie cross the accidental  
or rise above it, or are both required, which being user-selectable, as  
Neil suggested earlier?