Re: Issue 1110 in lilypond: Wrong octave of repetition chord with \relative and #{ #} syntax

[lilypond]

Comment #15 on issue 1110 by address@hidden: Wrong octave of repetition chord  
with \relative and #{ #} syntax
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=1110

Yes, you are naive.  q is processed much earlier, in the lexer and parser.   
But do you really want to have
\relative c' { <a' c e> q }
equivalent to
\relative c' { <a' c e> <a' c e> }
?  Think about it.  Or
\relative c' { <a c e> c e q }
equivalent to
\relative c' { <a c e> c e <a c e> }
?  That means that you _manually_ have to track the progress of pitch  
octaves, and compensate, and I don't even think that q' or q, are valid  
commands.

Basically, you are proposing to restart with the very first implementation  
of q, and then reopen all related closed bug reports in sequence again.  I  
doubt we'll end up somewhere else.