Re: Issue 2235 in lilypond: \partcombine: accidental reminders of first part lost

[lilypond]

Comment #4 on issue 2235 by address@hidden: \partcombine: accidental  
reminders of first part lost
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2235

I think, that almost ever the extra context is the reason for the  
accidental, and therefore would prefer, that it is shown in the combined  
part, where this extra context is also present. I would prefer this  
behavior although in most cases a more elegant way exists using automatic  
accidental rules.

Keeping the reminder accidental in the combined part is even better for  
people, who don't want the default behaviour:

<< \tag #'score b \tag #'part b! >>
could be written in the part with the reminder.
If the reminder is lost by default, you have to write
<< \tag #'score b! \tag #'part b >>
in the other part, which doesn't need the example for its own context.

Nevertheless: the behaviour at the moment is inconsistent, it should be the  
same wether the reminder is in the first or in the second part.