directory-discuss
[Top][All Lists]
Advanced

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: unetbootin


From: Narcis Garcia
Subject: Re: unetbootin
Date: Fri, 30 Dec 2022 09:55:12 +0100

El 29/12/22 a les 16:59, bill-auger ha escrit:
On Thu, 29 Dec 2022 07:53:58 +0100 Denis wrote:
Unetbootin probably works by extracting files from the iso and
modifying the syslinux arguments (in grub)

I was more thinking of users that use that tool only once to
install GNU/Linux and then hopefully never run Windows again.

there is a bit of confusion there - like im trying to argue,
this software is targeted at people who do not have _any_ linux
bootloader installed already, and who have no desire ever to
clobber the factory-installed proprietary bootloader -
unetbootin's unique function is to modify the _windows_
bootloader config, after expanding the ISO to disk - ie: it
ensures that windows always boots, regardless of how badly the
user messes up the "other OS" - it may be useful as a tool to
"never run Windows again"; but that was never its aim - 10-15
years ago, it was a simple way to try-out a new system; but
today, i suppose that the windows<->ubuntu compatibility
subsystem has displaced the wubi use-case - if windows users can
now install a nix on top of windows (as an app); there is little
incentive to mess with the bootloader

i have been arguing against the importance of this program; but
i do see it's value, if it were properly liberated - luckily, i
suppose that it is a very simple (easy to hack) program; so the
liberation would probably be quite easy to accomplish, if
someone wants to - liberation could be as simple as replacing a
single config file declaring the suggested downloads for the GUI


1. Most users don't know how to boot an external media.

2. Most users want to see how friendly is a GNU GUI before deciding to migrate to.

3. Most users want to know that their Windows setup will not be ruined before that decision.

4. Most of users that took the migration decision need to format a new partition or whole internal storage -> here "toram" mode is the key.

--
Narcis Garcia



reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]