Re: Shift-movement selection

[Richard Stallman]

    I have not properly followed the discussion.  Has anybody proposed or
    rejected adding some letter to the interactive string to mark
    shift-sensitive movement commands?  It would be reasonably easy to
    interpret this in C-h k and its ilk.

That could be a good method.  It has the advantage that the command
definition controls 100% of the behavior.

It is somewhat ugly that the command behaves differently depending on
what key it is bound to, but at least that happens according to a
simple system, which makes it less ugly than it might have been.