[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: GNU License, Again
From: |
Alfred M. Szmidt |
Subject: |
Re: GNU License, Again |
Date: |
Fri, 25 May 2007 21:56:45 +0200 |
> The original is no longer free, since it depends on a non-free work.
> The resulting work, a deriviate, is no longer free. And for the last
> time, the GPL cannot make anything free, only the copyright holder
> can.
How is the free code suddenly dependent on the non free work?
The non-free work is what's dependent on the free code, not
the other way around, in my scenario.
It is a _deriviate_, that is how it is dependant. It doesn't matter
what depends on what.
Imaging for a second that you have a work, to which you add some
non-free code. A user can no longer change the work as a whole, since
parts of it are not free. The GPL sees that an evil part cannot do
such things. It simply does not make anything free, it just sees that
the a free program stays free.
You could equally argue here that the free program does not depend on
the non-free parts, since the non-free parts only add functionality,
but that is not relevant, since the _WHOLE_ work is what matters.
Saying the "GPL makes things free" is a quick way of saying that
"the GPL requires you to make things free if you want to use other
free things (specifically, GPLed free things) in a certain
way". It's just a lot shorter, and I am surprised you want such
excruciating, exacting detail. Most people could get the drift of
what I'm saying.
It is the difference between pi being 3.14 and 4. One is a good
aproximation, the other is completely bogus.
- Re: GNU License, Again, (continued)
- Re: GNU License, Again, mike3, 2007/05/23
- Message not available
- Re: GNU License, Again, mike3, 2007/05/23
- Re: GNU License, Again, John Hasler, 2007/05/23
- Re: GNU License, Again, mike3, 2007/05/24
- Re: GNU License, Again, Alfred M. Szmidt, 2007/05/24
- Message not available
- Re: GNU License, Again, mike3, 2007/05/24
- Re: GNU License, Again, Alfred M. Szmidt, 2007/05/24
- Re: GNU License, Again, Tyler Smith, 2007/05/24
- Message not available
- Re: GNU License, Again, Alexander Terekhov, 2007/05/25
- Message not available
- Re: GNU License, Again, mike3, 2007/05/25
- Re: GNU License, Again,
Alfred M. Szmidt <=
- Message not available
- Re: GNU License, Again, Alexander Terekhov, 2007/05/25
- Message not available
- Re: GNU License, Again, mike3, 2007/05/25
- Message not available
- Re: GNU License, Again, David Kastrup, 2007/05/26
- Re: GNU License, Again, Alfred M. Szmidt, 2007/05/26
- Re: GNU License, Again, Alexander Terekhov, 2007/05/22
- Re: GNU License, Again, none, 2007/05/22
- Re: GNU License, Again, Alexander Terekhov, 2007/05/22
- Re: GNU License, Again, David Kastrup, 2007/05/22
- Re: GNU License, Again, Alexander Terekhov, 2007/05/22
- Re: GNU License, Again, mike3, 2007/05/24