[Top][All Lists]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: The GPL means what you want it to mean

Subject: Re: The GPL means what you want it to mean
Date: Tue, 7 Apr 2009 08:38:24 -0500
User-agent: slrn/ (Debian)

On 2009-04-06, Rjack <> wrote:
> JEDIDIAH wrote:
>> On 2009-04-06, amicus_curious <> wrote:
>>> "JEDIDIAH" <jedi@nomad.mishnet> wrote in message 
>>> news:slrngtkmgi.vvv.jedi@nomad.mishnet...
>>>>> GPL license offerers are much more akin to homeowners who are trying
>>>>> to rip off their invited guests by tempting them to accept an illegal
>>>>> contract.
>>>>   Nice self-nuke on your part there...
>>>>   You either have a legal contract or you are tresspassing.
>>> I don't think that you understood the analogy.  Let me put it in what might 
>>> be a more understandable form.  Say you go to Chicago for the Open Source 
>>> Expo and you and your buddies, being new to the big city, are wandering up 
>>> State Street and get enticed into a titty bar.  Then some sweet honeys cozy 
>>> up to you and ask you to buy them a drink.  "Sure!", you say, flattered by 
>>> such attention.  Then later you find that the tab for the girls' drinks are 
>>> not what you expected and are some $50 apiece.  "Pay up or we will call the 
>>> cops!" is what you are told.
>>> Now that is more akin to the way that unsophisticates are lured into using 
>>> the "free" GPL code and then are hammered for their birthright by the SFLC. 
>>> "Ignorance is no excuse!", they say, "What's yours is now ours, you have 
>>> been touched!" 
>> ...except the GPL is very plain and out in the open.
>> The intent of RMS is very clear and rather blunt.
>> The only way you can "misunderstand" anything is if it were
>> your original intent to try and "take advantage" to begin with.
>> The terms are by no stretch of the imagination hidden.
>> Neither is the intent of the proprietor.
> Boldness and clarity of purpose does not make that purpose legal.

...then the whole situation reverts to "straight property law".

You're attempt to have it both ways just wont fly.

    Microsoft: Because the world doesn't have enough peasants.        |||
                                                                     / | \

reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]