[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?
From: |
Graham Percival |
Subject: |
Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode? |
Date: |
Thu, 29 Apr 2010 22:35:28 +0100 |
User-agent: |
Mutt/1.5.18 (2008-05-17) |
On Thu, Apr 29, 2010 at 05:27:36PM -0400, Kieren MacMillan wrote:
> Hi all,
>
> > It's not obvious to me whether
> > c\chord #'(1 7)
> > should produce "c b" or "c bes". Musically speaking, I'd look at
>
> Or... we could use dodecaphonic intervals, i.e.
>
> c\chord #'(1 11) is a minor seventh
> c\chord #'(1 12) is a major seventh
>
> Of course, none of these ideas support systems with
> other-than-12-tones-per-octave… =(
Curse you! I got really excited when I read the first line, since
it seemed like a perfect solution. Then you go and wreck
everything.
You broke my heart. *sniff* *sniff* I'm going to go listen to
country music now. Screw you classical people with your math.
(or "maths" as they say here)
Cheers,
- Graham "my cat left me for a guy with a bigger hard drive"
PS: we could use a property to indicate the divisions of the
octave. Also, most of lilypond already assumes 12 notes per
octave, so this wouldn't be a huge (additional) limitation.
OTOH, most people writing chords just think/say "add a 7th", not
"add an 11th". Or rather, when they say "add an 11th", they're
not talking about semitones.
Cheers,
- Graham
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, (continued)
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Graham Percival, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Carl Sorensen, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Graham Percival, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Carl Sorensen, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, David Kastrup, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Graham Percival, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Kieren MacMillan, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?,
Graham Percival <=
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Carl Sorensen, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Karl Hammar, 2010/04/30
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, David Kastrup, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Carl Sorensen, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Carl Sorensen, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Graham Percival, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Carl Sorensen, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Graham Percival, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Karl Hammar, 2010/04/29
- Re: Why don't we get rid of \chordmode?, Reinhold Kainhofer, 2010/04/29