[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Unexpected result with FD solver
From: |
Jean Michel LECONTE |
Subject: |
Re: Unexpected result with FD solver |
Date: |
Mon, 17 Feb 2003 19:07:57 +0100 |
try :
ieq(LD1,LD2,Va):-
LD1 = [X1,X2,X3,X4],
LD2 = [D1,D2],
fd_domain(LD1,0,20),
fd_domain(LD2,1,12),
Va #=<5,
Va #>=0,
X1 #=0,
X2 #=< X1+4,
X2 #>= X1+2,
X3 #= X1+D1,
X4 #= X2+D2,
D1 #=< D2+Va,
D1 #>= D2-Va,
X4 #=< X3,
fd_labeling(LD1),
fd_labeling(LD2),
fd_labeling(Va).
read the note in the doc about fd_labeling, you have to do this operation if
you want some answers cause when gprolog says
LD1 = [0,_#25(2..4),_#47(3..12),_#69(3..12)]
LD2 = [_#91(3..12),_#113(1..10)]
Va = _#134(0..5)
it just means that Va could be between 0 and 5 but thts not meaning that
there's a solution...
gprolog tries to reduce the domain of possible values for each FD (i.e.
constrained) variable but if you want a solution you have to 'label' each FD
variable
and the _#integer(a..b) means FD variable which has integer for internal
system number (as an internal ID) is between a and b
Jean Michel LECONTE
-----------------------------------------
address@hidden
address@hidden
-----------------------------------------
Xiao-Hua Kong writes:
Hello,
I'm a beginer in Prolog, I want to use GNU Prolog for constraint sovling
in FD. I have tried the solver with a set of in-equations. But for some of
them, I did not get the result expected.
Here is an example:
I wrote a rule:
ieq(LD1,LD2,Va):-
LD1 = [X1,X2,X3,X4],
LD2 = [D1,D2],
fd_domain(LD1,0,20),
fd_domain(LD2,1,12),
Va #=<5,
Va #>=0,
X1 #= 0,
X2 #=< X1+4,
X2 #>= X1+2,
X3 #= X1+D1,
X4 #= X2+D2,
D1 #=< D2+Va,
D1 #>= D2-Va,
X4 #=< X3.
And asked for the possible assignment for these in-equations
(constraints).
However I got the follwing result:
| ?- ieq(LD1,LD2,Va).
LD1 = [0,_#25(2..4),_#47(3..12),_#69(3..12)]
LD2 = [_#91(3..12),_#113(1..10)]
Va = _#134(0..5)
In which the resulting domain of Va is larger than it should be. For
example, ask
| ?- ieq(LD1,LD2,0).
or | ?- ieq(LD1,LD2,1).
will have an answer "no".
Is there any problem with the code? Or I should not use more than three
variables in a constraint? How can I solve this problem.
BTW, what does _#integer mean in the result?
Thanks in advance.
Xiaohua Kong
_______________________________________________
Users-prolog mailing list
address@hidden
http://mail.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/users-prolog