[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[Bug gas/336] gas cannot assemble pdtlb,l instruction
From: |
nickc at redhat dot com |
Subject: |
[Bug gas/336] gas cannot assemble pdtlb,l instruction |
Date: |
31 Aug 2004 12:02:13 -0000 |
------- Additional Comments From nickc at redhat dot com 2004-08-31 12:02
-------
Subject: Re: gas cannot assemble pdtlb,l instruction
Hi Randolph,
> so, apparently, gas thinks that:
>
> pdtlb 0(%r29) -> valid for .level 1.1 or .level 2.0
> pdtlb %r0(%r29) -> ditto
> pdtlb,l 0(%r29) -> invalid always
> pdtlb,l %r0(%r29) -> valid iff .level 2.0
>
> i can't say that this is strictly wrong, just seems inconsistent :)
I agree. This behaviour is explicitly coded into the sources. if you
have a look at the header file include/opcodes/hppa.h and search for the
pdtlb instruction you will find four entries:
{ "pdtlb", 0x04001600, 0xfc003fdf, "cLcZx(s,b)", pa20, FLAG_STRICT},
{ "pdtlb", 0x04001600, 0xfc003fdf, "cLcZx(b)", pa20, FLAG_STRICT},
{ "pdtlb", 0x04001200, 0xfc003fdf, "cZx(s,b)", pa10, 0},
{ "pdtlb", 0x04001200, 0xfc003fdf, "cZx(b)", pa10, 0},
It is the presence of FLAG_STRICT which is forcing the assembler to
require an explicit register name for the "x" field. My assumption is
that this is because the HPPA 2.0 ISA specification tightened up the
syntax for the pdtlb instruction, ruling out register name
abbreviations. Presumably the "0" abbreviation is still supported for
level 1.1 since that might be used in already existing code. I cannot
be definitive about this since I did not write the code and I am not an
expert on the HPPA ISA.
Cheers
Nick
--
http://sources.redhat.com/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=336
------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are on the CC list for the bug, or are watching someone who is.
- [Bug gas/336] New: gas cannot assemble pdtlb,l instruction, tausq at debian dot org, 2004/08/17
- [Bug gas/336] gas cannot assemble pdtlb,l instruction, nickc at redhat dot com, 2004/08/27
- [Bug gas/336] gas cannot assemble pdtlb,l instruction, randolph at tausq dot org, 2004/08/27
- [Bug gas/336] gas cannot assemble pdtlb,l instruction, nickc at redhat dot com, 2004/08/27
- [Bug gas/336] gas cannot assemble pdtlb,l instruction, randolph at tausq dot org, 2004/08/27
- [Bug gas/336] gas cannot assemble pdtlb,l instruction, randolph at tausq dot org, 2004/08/27
- [Bug gas/336] gas cannot assemble pdtlb,l instruction,
nickc at redhat dot com <=