Re: Some more bug reports

[Mats Bengtsson]

Again, please use bug-lilypond for bug reports.
However, the 2 first issues look more like general usage questions
which belong to lilypond-user.

On the other hand, number 3 is clearly a bug, see below


Sebastiano Vigna wrote:
> 1) fretless.ly (always from vigna.dsi.unimi.it/music.php) does not
> compile because of a \markup command (ly-convert doesn't touch it).

convert-ly -e fretless.ly
works excellently here (replacing \column <...> with \column {...} in
the markups).


> 2) Like Spinning Plates complains that there is already music in the
> score, and the first line is oddly spaced. The font for text is much
> larger than it was previously.

You \score block
\score {
        \context GrandStaff
           #(set-accidental-style 'piano)
           <<
            ...
           >>
        \layout{...}
}

is equivalent to
\score {
        \context GrandStaff { #(set-accidental-style 'piano) }
           <<
             ...
           >>
        \layout{...}
}
which means that it has two music expressions at the top level
of \score{...}. You can only have one, so either do

\score {
        \context GrandStaff {
           #(set-accidental-style 'piano)
           <<
            ...
           >> }
        \layout{...}
}

or

\score {
        \context GrandStaff
           <<
           #(set-accidental-style 'piano)
            ...
           >>
        \layout{...}
}


> 3) At bar 53 of the included Sonata, the fingering is positioned
> incorrectly on the left hand. This was already true in 2.4.4, but it was
> such a minor thing that I thought to wait for the new version.

If you want to point out a bug, it's always better to reduce the .ly
file to a small example.

For example, the following small example illustrates the same problem,
namely that the fingerings collide with beams or even end up on the
wrong side of the beams.

\version "2.5.31"
\score{
\relative c{
\clef bass
\time 2/4
\key fis \minor
 fis,8 <b-2 d-1> <a-3 cis-1> <gis-4 b-2> |
 <fis-5 cis'-1>8 <e-4 cis'-1> <d-5 b'-1> <cis-4 ais'-1> |
\voiceTwo
 fis8 <b-2 d-1> <a-3 cis-1> <gis-4 b-2> |
 <fis-5 cis'-1>8 <e-4 cis'-1> <d-5 b'-1> <cis-4 ais'-1> |
}
}


   /Mats

> This is always with 2.5.31 under Fedora 4.
>
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> % Sonata K25 (Domenico Scarlatti)
> % Engraving by Sebastiano Vigna
>
> \version "2.4.3"
>
> \book {
>         \header {
>                 title = "Sonata K25"
>                 composer = "Domenico Scarlatti (1685$-$1757)"
>                 arranger = "Engraving by Sebastiano Vigna"
>         }
>
> \score {
> \header {
> 	piece ="Allegro" 
> }
> \context PianoStaff <<
> #(set-accidental-style 'piano)
> \override Score.SpacingSpanner #'shortest-duration-space = #2.5
>
> \context Staff = upper {
> 	\skip 1 * 10 
> }
> \context Staff = lower {
>         % #(override-auto-beam-setting '(end * * * *) 1 2 'Staff)
> 	\skip 1 * 10 
> }
>
> \context Staff = upper {
> \time 2/4
> \key fis \minor
> \relative c' {
>         fis16-2 a gis a fis cis b'-4 gis  a fis d'-4 b cis a gis'-5 f  fis 
> cis-2 d b cis-5 a b gis
>         
>         % 4
>         a4. gis16-2 f  fis8 b16-4 gis-1 a8-2 b16 gis
>         % 6
>         a16-2 cis fis-5 b,-2  e-4 a, d-3 gis,  cis-5 fis,-2 b-4 f-1 a-3 fis-1 
> b-4 gis a32-3 gis fis16
>                         fis' b,  e a, d gis,  cis fis, b f a-4 fis b gis a32 
> gis fis16
>                         fis' b,  e a, d gis,  cis fis, b f a-4 fis b-5 gis 
> a32-4 gis fis16
>         % 12 + 1/8
>         << { cis'8^\markup{M}[ d cis] } \\ { cis,16 fis a fis cis fis } >>
>         % 13
>         << { s8 cis'[ d cis] } \\ { gis16 f cis f gis f cis f } >>
>         << { s8 cis'8[ d cis] } \\ { a16 fis cis fis a fis cis fis } >>
>         << { s8 cis'[ d cis] } \\ { gis16 f cis f gis f cis f } >>
>         % 16
>         a16-5 cis,-2 c-1 gis' cis, fis e-3 dis  e-1 e' fis, dis' gis, gis' 
> cis,-2 fis-4  gis cis,-2 dis c  cis a' gis fis       
>         % 19
>         << { s8 gis[ a gis] } \\ { e32-1 dis-3 cis16 gis cis e-4 cis gis cis } 
> >>
>         << { s8 gis'[ a gis] } \\ { dis16-3 c gis c dis c gis c  } >>
>         << { s8 gis'[ a gis] } \\ { e16 cis gis cis e cis gis cis } >>
>         << { s8 gis'[ a gis] } \\ { dis16 c gis c dis c gis c  } >>
>         % 23
>         \stemUp
>         e32-3 dis cis16  a'-5 dis, gis-4 cis, fis-3 c
>         e32 dis cis16  a' dis, gis cis, fis c
>         e32 dis cis16  a' dis, gis cis, fis b,
>         \stemNeutral
>         % 26
>         << { s8 f'8[-3 fis-4 gis]-4 } \\ { f16-3 cis d-2 b  cis a d b  } >>
>         a' gis fis e-1  dis-4 cis b a  gis'-4 fis e-1 dis-3 e32 dis cis16 c-1 
> cis  dis a-1 gis-3 fis  e32 dis cis16 c cis
>         % 30
>         << { s8 gis'[ a gis] } \\ { dis16 c gis c dis c gis c  } >>
>         << { s8 gis'[ a gis] } \\ { e16 cis gis cis e cis gis cis  } >>
>         << { s8 gis'[ a gis] } \\ { dis16 c gis c dis c gis c  } >>
>         << { s8 gis'[ a gis] } \\ { e16 cis gis cis e cis gis cis  } >>
>         << { s8 gis'[ a gis] } \\ { dis16 c gis c dis c gis c  } >>
>         % 35
> 	e32-4 dis cis16 f-5 cis fis-4 cis gis'-5 cis,-1  a' cis, ais'-4 cis, c'-5 dis,-2 cis' e,  
> 	% 37
>         dis' gis, g gis g e' dis e  dis gis, g gis g g'-5 gis-4 g  gis gis, g 
> gis g e' dis e  dis gis, g gis g g' gis g
>         % 41
>         gis dis-1 cis-2 c cis fis-4 e dis  e a gis fis e-1 dis-3 cis c-1  cis-3 a b-5 gis 
> a-4 fis gis e  fis dis e32 dis cis16 <cis e>8 <c dis>
>         % 45
>         cis2\prall
>         
>         \pageBreak
>
>         % 
> =============================================================================================
>         
>         % 46
> 	cis16-1 gis'-4 fis gis  f-2 cis b'-4 gis  a fis d'-4 b cis a fis'-4 dis  f8 gis4 d8  cis[ b a gis] 
> 	% 50
>         \repeat unfold 3 { a32 gis fis16 d' gis, cis fis, b f } ais32-3 gis 
> fis16 g'-5 ais, fis'-4 b, e-5 cis
>         % 54
>         << { s8 fis[ g fis] } \\ { d32 cis b16 fis b d b fis b } >>
>         << { s8 fis'[ g fis] } \\ { cis16 ais fis ais cis ais fis ais } >>
>         << { s8 fis'[ g fis] } \\ { d16 b fis b d b fis b } >>
>         << { s8 fis'[ g fis] } \\ { cis16 ais fis ais cis ais fis ais } >>
>         << { s8 gis'[ ais gis] } \\ { dis16 b fis b dis b fis b } >>
>         << { s8 ais'[ b ais] } \\ { f16 d ais d f d ais d } >>
>         << { s8 ais'[ b ais] } \\ { fis16 dis ais dis fis dis ais dis } >>
>         << { s8 ais'[ b ais] } \\ { f16 d ais d f d ais d } >>
>         % 62
>         g16-5 dis e-4 cis dis b cis ais  c32-3 ais gis16 a'-5 dis, gis-4 cis, 
> fis dis
>         % 64
>         << { s8 f8[-3 fis-4 gis]-5 } \\ { e32-3 dis cis16 d-2 b cis a b gis } >> << { 
> a'8-4 ais-3 b-5 ais-4 } \\ { fis16-2 cis g'-2 e fis-2 d g-3 e-2 } >>
>         % 66
>         \stemUp
>         << { b'32 a gis16 fis f-1 fis-4 d cis b } \\ { d8 } >>
>         b'32 a gis16 fis f fis cis-4 b a
>         << { b'32 a gis16 fis f fis d cis b } \\ { d8 } >>
>         b'32 a gis16 fis f fis cis-3 b a
>         { b'32 a gis16 f fis gis b,-2 a gis }
>         \stemNeutral
>         % 71
>         \repeat unfold 2 { a32 gis fis16 d' gis, cis fis, b f } a32 gis fis16 
> fis'-5 b, e-4 a, d gis,  cis fis, b f a32-4 gis fis16 f fis-2
>         % 75
>         << { s8 cis'[ d cis] } \\ { gis16 f cis f gis f cis f } >>
>         << { s8 cis'8[ d cis] } \\ { a16 fis cis fis a fis cis fis } >>
>         << { s8 cis'[ d cis] } \\ { gis16 f cis f gis f cis f } >>
>         << { s8 cis'8[ d cis] } \\ { a16 fis cis fis a fis cis fis } >>
>         << { s8 cis'[ d cis] } \\ { gis16 f cis f gis f cis f } >>
>         % 80
>         \repeat unfold 2 { a32 gis fis16 d'-5 gis, cis-4 fis, b-3 f } a32 gis 
> fis16 fis'-5 b, e-4 a, d gis,
>         % 83
> 	cis-3 fis, b'-5 gis a fis gis f  fis32 gis a16  b32 a gis16 a32 gis fis16  gis32 fis f16 
> 	% 85
>         fis32 e d16 e32 d cis16 d32 cis b16 cis32 b a16 b32 a gis16 a32 gis fis16 <fis 
> a>8 <f gis> fis2\prall
>         
>         
> }
> }
> \context Staff = lower {
> \key fis \minor
> \clef bass
> \relative c { 
> 	s1.
>         
>         %4
>         fis16[-3 a gis a]  fis[ cis b' gis]  a[ fis-4 d'-1 b]-4  cis[-3 a gis' 
> f]
>         % 6
>         fis8 d cis b-1  a gis fis-1 cis   fis,\noBeam d'' cis b   a gis fis cis 
>   fis,\noBeam d'' cis b   a gis fis cis
>         % 12
>         fis8 s4.  cis8_\markup{M} s4.  fis8 s4. cis8 s4.
>         % 16
>         fis8-4 gis a c \clef treble cis-4 dis e a  gis fis e-1 dis
>         % 19
>         cis8 s4. \clef bass  gis8 s4. cis,8 s4. gis'8 s4.
>         % 23
>         %\change Staff = upper \stemDown
>         \clef treble
>         cis8 fis e dis  cis fis e dis  cis fis e d
>         %\change Staff = lower \stemNeutral
>         \clef bass
>         % 26
>         cis8 b-1 a gis fis a b dis, e gis a,[ a'] gis-2 c,-5 cis-3 a-5
>         % 30
>         gis8 s4.  cis8 s4.  gis8 s4. cis,8 s4. gis'8 s4.
>         % 35
>         cis8 b'-1 a gis fis e-1 dis-3 cis
>         % 37
>         gis'8 gis <dis' cis ais>8 <dis cis ais>8 \repeat unfold 3 { <gis, dis'> <gis dis'> 
> <dis' cis ais>8 <dis cis ais>8 }
>         % 41
> 	<gis,-5 dis'-1>8 <fis-3 dis'-1> <e-5 cis'-2> <dis-4 c'-1> <cis cis'> fis gis[ gis,] a' gis fis e-1 dis cis gis'[ gis,] 
> 	% 45
>         cis,2 \bar ":|:" \break
>
>         % 
> =============================================================================================
>         
>         % 46
>         s2 s2 cis'16[-5 gis'-1 fis gis]  f[-3 cis b' gis]-3  a[ fis d'-1 b]-4  
> cis[ a f'-1 cis]-2
>         % 50
>         \repeat unfold 2 { fis,8 <b-2 d-1> <a-3 cis-1> <gis-4 b-2> } fis8 <b d> <a cis> <g b>  
> <fis-5 cis'-1>8 <e-4 cis'-1> <d-5 b'-1> <cis-4 ais'-1>
>         % 54
>         <b b'>8 s4.  fis'8 s4. b,8 s4. fis'8 s4. b8 s4. ais8 s4. dis8 s4. ais8 
> s4.
>         % 62
>         dis,8 cis'-2 b-1 ais  gis fis e-1 dis-3
>         % 64
>         cis b' a gis fis e-1 dis cis
>         % 66
>         b4 ~ b16 \change Staff = upper b''_2 a gis \change Staff = lower
>         a,4 ~ a16 \change Staff = upper a' gis fis \change Staff = lower
>         b,4 ~ b16 \change Staff = upper b' a gis \change Staff = lower
>         a,4 ~ a16 \change Staff = upper a' gis fis
> 	\stemDown 
> 	% \override Voice.Stem #'length = #9 
> 	\override Voice.Stem #'stem-shorten = #'(0 0)
>         gis4 ~ gis16 gis fis f_1 \change Staff = lower \stemNeutral
>         \revert Voice.Stem #'stem-shorten
>         % 71
>         fis8-2 <b, d> <a cis> <gis b> <fis a> <b d> <a cis> <gis b> fis d' cis b-1 <a-4 cis-2> 
> <gis-3 b-1> <fis a> <d-5 b'-1>
>         % 75
>         cis8 s4. fis,8 s4. cis8 s4. fis8 s4. cis8 s4.
>         % 80
>         fis'8 <b d> <a cis> <gis b> <fis a> <b d> <a cis> <gis b> <fis a> d' 
> cis b
>         % 83
> 	<a-4 cis-2> gis fis cis'-2 d b cis[ cis,] <d d'> <cis cis'> <b b'> <a a'> <gis gis'> <fis fis'> <cis cis'> <cis cis'> fis2 
> 	\bar "|."
>         
> }
> }
>
>
> %       \midi { \tempo4=80 }
>         \layout { 
> 	  indent = 0\mm
>           raggestlast = ##t
>         }
> }
>
> }
>
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> _______________________________________________
> lilypond-devel mailing list
> address@hidden
> http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-devel

--
=============================================
        Mats Bengtsson
        Signal Processing
        Signals, Sensors and Systems
        Royal Institute of Technology
        SE-100 44  STOCKHOLM
        Sweden
        Phone: (+46) 8 790 8463                         
        Fax:   (+46) 8 790 7260
        Email: address@hidden
        WWW: http://www.s3.kth.se/~mabe
=============================================