Re: clef collides with rest

[Jay Anderson]

Ok, here's what I've come up with to show the bug a little better:

-----
\version "2.9.21"

\score
{
 <<
   \new Staff
   {
     \relative c'
     {
       c4 c c c |
       c4 c8 c c4 c8 c |
       c8 c4 c8 c c4 c8 |
       c8 c c c c c c c |
       \times 2/3 {c4 c c} c4 c |
       c4 \times 2/3 {c4 c c} c4 |
       c4 c \times 2/3 {c4 c c} |
       \times 2/3 {c4 c c} \times 2/3 {c c c} |
     }
   }
   \new Staff
   {
     \repeat unfold 8 {\clef treble d''4 r \clef bass f r |}
   }
 >>
 \layout
 {
   indent = #0
   line-width = #30
 }
}

-----

I know this is artifically compressing the systems, but it's the
closest I could get it to how lilypond formatted it automatically for
me in the real piece. In any case the bass clef is misplaced in
measures 3, 5, and 8. In the good measures the rest's position is
adjusted to make room for the clef while in these it is not.

I'll see if I can isolate the bad tie problem a bit later. Thanks again.

-----Jay

On 10/6/06, Werner LEMBERG <address@hidden> wrote:
> > By 'better' I meant that it shows the problem more clearly. I haven't
> > tweaked much at all yet. This is default Lilypond and it doesn't
> > complain one bit about it getting too dense:
>
> The new image definitely classifies the collision as a bug.  It would
> be great if you could extract a minimal example (probably by reducing
> the line length), reducing it as much as possible.
>
> BTW, there is another bug hidden in the image: the tie in the bass
> line from the first to the second bar appears as a dot only.  This is
> something serious...  According to your other mails I presume that you
> already use the latest lilypond version.  Again I ask you to isolate
> the problem to the smallest possible case.  I know that it is quite
> time consuming, but it enormously increases the chances to get a quick
> fix.
>
> > I've done this to make it smaller:
> >
> > -----
> >     \new Staff
> >     \with
> >    {
> >       fontSize = #-3
> >       \override StaffSymbol #'staff-space = #(magstep -3)
> >     }
> >     {\hornNotes}
> > -----
> >
> > Is this not good practice?
>
> This is fine, I think.
>
>
>     Werner

bug2a.png
Description: PNG image