Re: Grace notes cause clef-change positioning problem

[Jonathan Kulp]

It *does* use the horizontal space optimally, but I don't think I've 
ever seen a published score where it looks like this.  I'd have to check 
a notation style manual to know if it's a rule, but I'm pretty sure the 
clef is supposed to come before the barline.   Anyway the trick using 
\grace {s4} places the clef exactly where I want it, so there's no 
reason to change the current behavior.  Best,

Jon

Werner LEMBERG wrote:
> > Notice how in the lower staff when the clef changes from alto to
> > treble, the treble clef is shoved all the way into the next bar
> > instead of remaining behind the barline.  When I take out the grace
> > notes from the upper staff, the clef change happens as expected.  Is
> > this a bug?
>
> Actually, I like this behaviour.  It uses the horizontal space in an
> optimal way.  However, I don't know whether this `solution' is
> intentionally selected by lilypond or caused unexpectedly.
>
>
>     Werner

--
Jonathan Kulp
http://www.jonathankulp.com