Re: bug with baseline-skip in markup-list-commands?

[Thomas Morley]

2015-08-06 7:09 GMT+02:00 David Kastrup <address@hidden>:
> Thomas Morley <address@hidden> writes:
>
>> Hi,
>>
>> look at the following code (png attached)
>>
>> \version "2.19.24"
>>
>> mrkpI =
>> \markup
>>  {
>>   \override #'(baseline-skip . 10)
>>   \column \box { "xy" "xy" "xy" "xy" }
>>  }
>>
>> mrkpII =
>> \markuplist
>>  {
>>   \override-lines #'(baseline-skip . 10)
>>   \column-lines \box { "xy" "xy" "xy" "xy" }
>>  }
>>
>> \markup \line { \box \mrkpI \box \column \mrkpII }
>>
>>
>> The markup-list-version for baseline-skip adds space even above top
>> and below bottom line.
>> Responsible is 'space-lines' from define-markup-commands.scm.
>> (used in justified-lines, wordwrap-lines, column-lines)
>>
>> Is this really intended?
>
> I think so.


Meanwhile I've found with gitk:

Author: Nicolas Sceaux <address@hidden>  2008-07-14 12:39:23
Committer: Nicolas Sceaux <address@hidden>  2008-07-14 12:39:23
Parent: cb3ce391f2f9e247dd4f9c1b34f169f0ba42b50c (Add definitions for
arabic music.)
Child:  af59cf12f9792c5fb6d9cb7be2242ba8beef7831 (GDP NR 3.5 MIDI support)
Follows: release/2.11.52-1
Precedes: release/2.11.53-1, release/2.11.53-2

    \markuplines: fix space between \justified-lines groups

    space-lines: Also add space around the first and last lines of a
    group, so that the spacing between paragraphs is even wrt to the
    spacing inside a paragraph.

@Bug-squad:
So far it's indeed intended.
The patch does what it promises.

The resulting problems may need further discussion/design-decision on
the devel-list, though

No bug so far.

Cheers,
  Harm