Re: Melody_engraver and tied notes

[Paul Hodges]

Gould illustrates this happening for beamed quavers (page 64), but doesn't 
address this exact case of crotchets that I can find.


Paul



 From:   Simon Albrecht <simon.albrecht@mail.de> 
 To:   Lilypond bug list <bug-lilypond@gnu.org> 
 Sent:   28/02/2023 11:41 
 Subject:   Melody_engraver and tied notes 

Hello everyone, 
 
Melody_engraver readily sets different stem directions either side of a  
tie. I don’t think it should do that. 
 
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 
\version "2.25.2" 
 
\layout { 
   \context { 
     \Voice 
     \remove Note_heads_engraver 
     \consists Completion_heads_engraver 
     \consists Melody_engraver 
   } 
} 
\relative { 
   d''2. b4~ 4 g2 b2 d2. 
} 
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 
 
Technically, not a minimal example, since Completion_heads_engraver  
isn’t really related. I just figured I include it to be safe, in case  
behaviour differs in any way with regard to potential fixes. 
 
Best, Simon