[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: GPL traitor !
From: |
Tim Smith |
Subject: |
Re: GPL traitor ! |
Date: |
Fri, 08 May 2009 10:44:48 -0700 |
User-agent: |
MT-NewsWatcher/3.5.3b2 (Intel Mac OS X) |
In article <85d4ajj046.fsf@lola.goethe.zz>, David Kastrup <dak@gnu.org>
wrote:
> What is covered is a matter of copyright law. Which is the case with
> any software license or contract. Getting copyright law right is hard
> and a moving overly complex target, different in different countries.
>
> But that's hardly a fault with the GPL, let alone the FSF.
Exactly--and that's why the very first question to be asked when
considering whether you can or cannot do something with a given blob of
GPL code is *not* "what does GPL say?", but rather "does it matter what
GPL says?".
That's also the very first question to ask when dealing with non-GPL
code, whether it is under a pure copyright license, or a contract
(assuming GPL is not a contract).
In fact, that's also the first question to ask when dealing with a
contract that has nothing to do with code--one of the first lessons in
my contracts class in law school was to make sure the contract applies
before you spend a lot of time analyzing the details of the contract.
Many a contract professor has put a problem on their final exam with a
complex contract and a fact pattern that doesn't actually fall under the
contract, and many a student has wasted a lot of valuable time writing
up a long analysis of that contract, instead of writing the correct
answer: "the contract is not applicable".
--
--Tim Smith
- Re: GPL traitor !, (continued)
- Re: GPL traitor !, Alan Mackenzie, 2009/05/08
- Re: GPL traitor !, Doctor Smith, 2009/05/08
- Re: GPL traitor !, Alan Mackenzie, 2009/05/11
- Re: GPL traitor !, Alexander Terekhov, 2009/05/11
- Re: GPL traitor !, Alan Mackenzie, 2009/05/08
- Re: GPL traitor !, David Kastrup, 2009/05/08
- Re: GPL traitor !,
Tim Smith <=
- Re: GPL traitor !, Rjack, 2009/05/08
- Re: GPL traitor !, Alan Mackenzie, 2009/05/08
- Re: GPL traitor !, Rjack, 2009/05/08
- Re: GPL traitor !, Alan Mackenzie, 2009/05/09
- Re: GPL traitor !, Hyman Rosen, 2009/05/08
- Re: GPL traitor !, Alan Mackenzie, 2009/05/08
- Re: GPL traitor !, Hyman Rosen, 2009/05/08
- Re: GPL traitor !, Hadron, 2009/05/08
- Re: GPL traitor !, Alan Mackenzie, 2009/05/09
- Re: GPL traitor !, Rjack, 2009/05/09