Re: No Followup-To header defaults

[Haines Brown]

Reiner Steib <reinersteib+from-uce@imap.cc> writes:

> On Thu, Aug 25 2005, Haines Brown wrote:
>
>> I've cut out everything in ~/.gnus except for
>>
>>   (setq gnus-select-method '(nntp "..."))
>>
>> and the problem persists. 
>
> Which problem?  The prompt "Really post to these unknown groups: x,
> y?"?  

Yes.

> Gnus doesn't know that groups x and y exist.  Maybe in your previous
> setup, Gnus knew about the groups x and y (IIRC unsubscrkilledibed
> groups are also considered here).

I had assumed that when I followed up to a message, the header of my
reply would read the Newsgroups: line of the message to which I am
responding. Your answer implies that this not so, and the behavior
about which I'm complaining is normal. 

You seem to imply that in my previous setup gnus didn't read the
Newsgroups: line, but would somehow otherwise know of these groups,
even if I had never subscribed to them or killed them. 

For example, I'm involved in a discussion on a newsgroup, but the OP
had distributed his message to several groups, including
uk.politics.misc. When I follow up to up his messages, the
uk.politics.misc group in my old setup would appear automatically in
the "Newsgroups:" line of my outgoing header.

Since you may be suggesting that my old gnus somehow knew of
uk.politis.misc, I searched in ~/News and the ~/.newsrc* files, but
didn't find it.

In my old setup, ~/News contained a set of files corresponding to the
groups to which I subscribed. For example, linux.debian.user.SCORE,
which holds the sole line "(("references"))". My new set up has no
such files. 

In the original setup, In the file for the newsgroup to which I reply
to message with multiple addresses, the entry has sets of lines like
these: 

  (("references"
    ("<871x5lp9ve.fsf@teufel.hartford-hwp.com>[ ]*$" nil 732153 r)
    ("<871x5lp9ve.fsf@teufel.hartford-hwp.com>" nil 732153 s)
  ...


-- 
 
       Haines Brown
       KB1GRM