On Feb 24, 2011, at 10:21 PM, Bertrand Bordage wrote:
Hi,You're cheating a bit, Mike !This wasn't "c'4~ c'8." instead of "a4~ a8." in the lower voice.It's even more tight !Here is the example in context (Breitkopf und Härtel 1878) :The last two systems of the second page.You can also notice a similar case on the last PDF page. Last system, measure 2, third beat, upper staff.I also have many other cases of "three-voices-tight-situations" in more recent editions, especially Bärenreiter.I saw one day a XIXth century book with VERY tight music everywhere. Something like 6 voices Preludes and Fuges everywhere. Of course, beautifully engraved. If I could find it again... This thing is really the bible of beam collisions !Now I have to go away for the WE.Regards,Bertrand
Caught red-handed! I had changed it to an A when I was testing how far down the collision detection would go. But Bertrand's right: the original is even tighter (and attached in both the current master and my issue 37 work).
