[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047)
From: |
dak |
Subject: |
Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047) |
Date: |
Sun, 17 Nov 2013 06:41:06 +0000 |
Just that Devon does not get a wrong impression: I applaud every effort
to make LilyPond's MIDI output better reflect its input, and this work
is a great step in that direction.
Dan, however, suggests to make LilyPond's output to reflect not the
music but an imaginary performance by a human player, making the MIDI
worse suitable for proofhearing.
And that's a direction that makes no sense, because there is other
specialized software for that job. LilyPond's MIDI output is intended
to convey information, not emotion.
It would be an ambitious task to "properly" convey "con fuoco" or "molto
triste" like a human player would, but the MIDI way would be to crank up
or down the speed and the expression controller.
https://codereview.appspot.com/26470047/
- Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), (continued)
- Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), Dan Eble, 2013/11/15
- Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), Devon Schudy, 2013/11/15
- Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), Dan Eble, 2013/11/16
- Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), David Kastrup, 2013/11/16
- Message not available
- Message not available
- Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), Dan Eble, 2013/11/17
- Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), David Kastrup, 2013/11/17
- Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), Dan Eble, 2013/11/17
Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047),
dak <=
Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), dak, 2013/11/17
Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), ianhulin44, 2013/11/17
Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), dak, 2013/11/19
Re: Support articulations, slurs and breaths in MIDI (issue 26470047), k-ohara5a5a, 2013/11/23