Re: bar check bug in Lilypond 2.22.2 ??

[Flaming Hakama by Elaine]

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Kenneth Wolcott <kennethwolcott@gmail.com>
To: Lily Pond <lilypond-user@gnu.org>
Cc: 
Bcc: 
Date: Thu, 20 Oct 2022 15:01:05 -0700
Subject: bar check bug in Lilypond 2.22.2 ??
Hi;

bar check bug in Lilypond 2.22.2 ??

I must be doing something dumb!

I am not able to find the cause of a bar check warning occurring at
the same bar (#85) in all five parts.

time is 4/4

Workaround was to disable bar checks at bar #85 and beyond.

This works until time is 2/4.  Then it starts warning again, with bar
checks still off.

I even had a second pair of eyes (piano player) see if "quarter rest,
dotted quarter eighth and quarter note" fills 4/4 time.

Something weird here.

I have attached the origin pdf, my engraved pdf and the Lilypond source.

Thanks,
Ken Wolcott

The problem is that you are copying an error in the original.

In that bar, which is still 3/2 time, there is only 2 half notes' worth of duration 

If you want to preserve the error, either add a half note spacer, or multiply the half note by 2 to have it fill up the remainder of the bar.  

Or fix the error and change either the value to a whole note, or add a half note rest.

For example, in the trumpet part it is this 2nd to last line that is missing the half note value

trumpet_one = {

\global

\clef treble

d'2\f | % m00

d'4 e' g' fs'8 fs' a'4 b'8 b' | % m01

d''4 cs''8 cs'' e''4 g''8 g'' fs''4 e''8 e'' | % m02

d''4 d''8 d'' d''2 d''4 cs'' | % m03

\mBreak

b'2 a'4 a''8 g'' fs'' e'' d'' cs'' | % m04

b'2 a'\fermata d'' | % m05

d''4 a' a' g'8 g' b'4 a'8 a' | % m06

d''4 a' a' b'8 b' d''4 cs''8 cs'' | % m07

\mBreak

fs''4 d'' g''2 fs''4 e'' | % m08

a''1 g''4 fs'' | % m09

e''2 d'' g''4 fs'' | % m10

e''1. | % m11

\mBreak

d''1\fermata

\bar "|."

% \repeat volta 2 {

r2 | % m12

R1*3/2 | % m13

r4 a' a' cs'' d''8 fs'' e'' fs'' | % m14

\mBreak

d''8 fs' g' b' a'2

r8 e'' d'' e'' cs'' e'' d'' cs'' d''4 cs''8 e'' | % m15

HTH, 

Elaine Alt

415 . 341 .4954                                           "Confusion is highly underrated"

elaine@flaminghakama.com

Producer ~ Composer ~ Instrumentalist ~ Educator

-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-