Re: [gnugo-devel] Bad testcases

[Arend Bayer]

Gunnar wrote:

> I wrote:
> > The following test cases have at least one occupied vertex among the
> > correct (or incorrect in the negated case) answers:
>
> > 13x13:50
>
> Possibly M10 should be M8, the actual game move. Arend?

Yes.

> > handtalk:6
>
> F16 was probably intended to be the game move at E16. It doesn't look
> all that horrible, although G13 is locally better. I propose changing
> the test to
>
> 6 restricted_genmove black E16 G13
> #? [G13]

The point is that F16 is too small. I agree with that change.

> > handtalk:10
>
> No idea what was intended instead of D8. We have two other answers and
> a comment that more moves are possible. For now I propose just
> deleting D8.

I don't remember what I intended. D12 might be an alternative.

> > nngs3:310
>
> C5 should be C4?

I'd suggest
#? [B5|B7|D7|C4]

Their results don't differ too much. (But not tenuki!!)

> > tactics1:106
>
> No idea what F9 should be.

F6 is fine (might even be best).

Arend