[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Bugreport: Accidental Modern bug when partial bar first
From: |
Donald Axel |
Subject: |
Bugreport: Accidental Modern bug when partial bar first |
Date: |
Sun, 30 Jul 2006 09:45:33 +0200 |
This is an edited reposting of a bugreport. I am reposting so that
it is not forgotten amidst a long thread.
The bug is a minor (small) bug concerning accidental-rules.
After reading documentation (see link below) and experimenting with
Lily-2.8.5 I think Marco Gusy has discovered a bug. If the partial bar
has a natural C then the "modern" rules are ignored, no natural sign
appears in the attached example with a partial bar. The partial bar
natural C should not influence the application of the "modern"-rule
in the next full bar.
The attached PNGs show the bug with "modern" style.
As there has been some discussion there may be need for a very
explicit explanation:
The "modern"-rule says that "[...] temporary accidentals are also
cancelled in other octaves."
Therefore the bars before the temporary accidentals should not
influence the "modern"-rule.
(Same applies to modern-cautionary which works differently
from the documentation when there is a partial bar first.)
Using the documentation example:
% ****************************************************************
% ly snippet contents follows:
% ****************************************************************
#(set-accidental-style 'modern-cautionary)
cis' c'' cis'2 | c'' c'
% ***end***
Adding natural C as partial first bar changes the subsequent bar:
% ****************************************************************
% ly snippet contents follows:
% ****************************************************************
#(set-accidental-style 'modern) % applies to modern-cautionary (too).
\partial 4
c'' |
cis' c'' cis'2 | c'' c'
% ***end***
http://lilypond.org/doc/v2.8/Documentation/user/lilypond/Automatic-accidentals.html#Automatic-accidentals
docu-acc-modern.png
Description: PNG image
docu-acc-modern-pre4.png
Description: PNG image
- Bug or Feature?, Marco Gusy, 2006/07/12
- Re: Bug or Feature?, Marco Gusy, 2006/07/13
- Re: Bug or Feature?, Mats Bengtsson, 2006/07/19
- Re: Bug or Feature?, Marco Gusy, 2006/07/25
- Re: No Bug nor Feature?, Donald Axel, 2006/07/25
- Re: No Bug nor Feature?, Marco Gusy, 2006/07/26
- List-culture [was] No Bug nor Feature?, Donald Axel, 2006/07/26
- Re: List-culture [was] No Bug nor Feature?, Marco Gusy, 2006/07/27
- Modern-acc. bug when partial bar first, Donald Axel, 2006/07/27
- Bugreport: Accidental Modern bug when partial bar first,
Donald Axel <=
- Re: Bug or Feature?, Joe Neeman, 2006/07/25