[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator
From: |
David Kastrup |
Subject: |
Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator |
Date: |
Sun, 14 Nov 2021 17:32:49 +0100 |
User-agent: |
Gnus/5.13 (Gnus v5.13) Emacs/28.0.50 (gnu/linux) |
Kieren MacMillan <kieren@kierenmacmillan.info> writes:
> Hi David,
>
>> How is that uniquely identified? Why couldn't it be subscripted with 10
>> instead of 5?
>
> I suppose it could. It could also be subscripted with a π or a √2. I
> can’t stop people from doing what they want to do.
>
> Simultaneously true is the fact that the musical duration “one
> quintuplet-sixteenth” has one and only one visual representation,
> regardless of what Lilypond thinks or is told to do.
Again you are evading the stated problem. The question was about the
representation of time signature 8/20, not about "one
quintuplet-sixteenth". 8/20 does not specify more than the basic
subdivision for expressing beats (not necessarily identical with the
number of beats as signatures like 9/8 show) and how much material fits
a bar. It does not identify how that material may be structured or
expressed, in opposition to your and Carl's statements about what
meaning the parts of a time signature are supposed to inherently have,
leading to a proposal of generally changing the current representation
by involving musical durations for the denominator.
--
David Kastrup
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, (continued)
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, David Kastrup, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Kieren MacMillan, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, David Kastrup, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Kieren MacMillan, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, David Kastrup, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Kieren MacMillan, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Kieren MacMillan, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Kieren MacMillan, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, David Kastrup, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Kieren MacMillan, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator,
David Kastrup <=
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Kieren MacMillan, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, David Kastrup, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Kieren MacMillan, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Carl Sorensen, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, David Kastrup, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Lukas-Fabian Moser, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Lukas-Fabian Moser, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Kieren MacMillan, 2021/11/14
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, Wols Lists, 2021/11/16
- Re: TimeSignature with note in denominator, David Kastrup, 2021/11/16