Re: Multiple instances of same articulation/bowing on one note

[kieren]

Hi all,

I would personally consider that a bug!
script-engraver.cc:

void
Script_engraver::listen_articulation (Stream_event *ev)
{
  /* Discard double articulations for part-combining.  */
  for (vsize i = 0; i < scripts_.size (); i++)
    if (scm_is_eq (get_property (scripts_[i].event_, "articulation-type"),
                   get_property (ev, "articulation-type")))
      return;


Umm...

 

The fact that it's coded doesn’t make it not a bug… ;)

 

Should this be stripped down to a single markup without warning?

 

{ g_\markup "umm…" ^\markup "umm…" }

 

If the user intentionally doubles anything — be it articulation, markup, dynamic, or whatever — I consider it a bug it it’s stripped from the output. <shrug>

 

Kieren.