Re: [External] : Re: Concern about new binding.

[Ergus]

On Sun, Feb 07, 2021 at 06:43:31PM +0000, Drew Adams wrote:
> > And I've now moved the binding to `C-x x g', which should un-annoy
> > Magit users.
> >
> > There's been suggestions for other buffer-related commands to put on
> > the `C-x x' keymap, and I'm adding a few of those, too.  Feel free to make
> > further suggestions.
>
> Please don't bind `C-x x' by default.  That's
> my suggestion.
>
> Bookmark+ uses `C-x x' (having been forced off
> of `C-x p').
What if (just getting crazy) you consider adding some/most of the
bookmark+ functionalities to vanilla and they will go in the `C-x r` map
with the other bookmark commands (C-x r b, C-x r m and so on)???  Like
diredx for dired or and many other examples...

Even extending the current `C-x r` is a better choice than taking a
binding only for this... It will help to discover the commands when
using which-key for example and avoid the user learn and sacrifice
another prefix combination.

I don't want to argue about this, it is just a suggestion because I
wanted to use bookmark+ long time ago, but I finally never tried it
because 1) it is not in elpa or melpa or vanilla (so I will need to
manually maintain it updates) and 2) because I will have to sacrifice a
binding just for it...

It is just my opinion...