Re: Problems with musicxml2ly

[Silvain Dupertuis]

I do not think the problem is with the msl format, which is an archive containing a xml file.

I tried on another mxl file directly and it worked. But it was actually a score coming from Lilypond.
In the case of Minuit, I tried extracting the xml file from the mxl file and using musicxml2ly on the mxl archive gives the same result (and the same errors)...

Le 20.12.22 à 09:36, Jacques Menu a écrit :

Hello Mark,

Unfortunately I do not know any way to produce a small  xml  that will give this error.

The file I wanted was "O holy night" by Adolphe Adam (translated into English) adapted

by P. Le Bas.

It came from this address:

 https://www.cpdl.org/wiki/index.php/Minuit,_chr%C3%A9tiens_(O_Holy_Night)_(Adolphe_Charles_Adam)#In_English_translation.2C_.22O_Holy_Night.22

The legend on this page is misleading: the files that can be downloaded clicking on the supposedly MusicXML icon have a ‘.mxl’ suffix, i.e. they are MuseScore files in fact:

I know, it’s unfortunate that this suffix is so close to ‘.xml’…

The first page this gives in the recent MuseScore 4.0.0r is:

Exporting all the parts to MusicXML produces the attached O_Holy_Night.xml file. Note that MusicXML is a textual format, and one can open such files with any text editor:

Here again. a suffix point: historically, MusicXML has used ‘.xml’, which is marked as obsolete by MuseScore. An attempt to change that to ‘.musicxml’ doesn’t seem to have gained approval yet, though.

Converting O_Holy_Night.xml to LilyPond with:

musicxml2ly (LilyPond) 2.23.82

Copyright (c) 2005--2022 by

    Han-Wen Nienhuys <hanwen@xs4all.nl>,

    Jan Nieuwenhuizen <janneke@gnu.org> and

    Reinhold Kainhofer <reinhold@kainhofer.com>

    Patrick L. Schmidt <pls@philomelos.net>

produces the attached O_Holy_Night.ly, converted to the attached O_Holy_Night.pdf file by LilyPond.

HTH!

JM

--
Silvain Dupertuis
Route de Lausanne 335
1293 Bellevue (Switzerland)
tél. +41-(0)22-774.20.67
portable +41-(0)79-604.87.52
web: silvain-dupertuis.org